GamesGenshin Impact
Genshin Impact review: why it’s so successful, how it makes money, and what players really say
A console-grade open world handed out for free, then paid for one wish at a time.
App Store
4.23★
575K ratings
Google Play
3.19★
5.2M ratings
Installs (Play)
100,000,000+
official range
US grossing
Perennial top-grossing mobile game worldwide; one of the highest-earning gacha titles since 2020, still charting years after launch
Global Grossing · RPG / Adventure
What this analysis is
We read 59 recent reviews of Genshin Impact across the App Store (50) and Google Play (9), 22 positive and 37 negative, to find what players actually praise and complain about. Every percentage below is counted from those real reviews; the ratings, install range, and chart rank are the stores’ own public figures. We never invent downloads or revenue, those aren’t public, so we don’t pretend to know them. Here’s what makes Genshin Impactwork, and where it doesn’t.
Why Genshin Impact is so successful
Standing observed from its continuous presence on the App Store and Google Play top-grossing game charts across major markets; a precise live rank was not verified at capture time, so no exact number is claimed. A Adventure (open-world action RPG, gacha) game by COGNOSPHERE PTE. LTD. (HoYoverse), released Sep 26, 2020, it combines 5.8M+ total ratings across both stores with a few things players consistently single out:
- It gives away a genuinely console-tier open world for zero dollars. Reviewers who came in skeptical of gacha still call the exploration, traversal, and scale 'amazing' and say they never HAD to spend to play.
- The presentation is a moat. The art style, real-time lighting, character animation, and an orchestral soundtrack (London Philharmonic, Shanghai Symphony) get named directly in five-star reviews as reasons people stay.
- Character collection is the emotional hook. A large, distinctly-designed cast with voiced stories turns pulling the gacha into 'getting your favorite' rather than just rolling stats, which is why players talk about specific characters (Kinich, etc.) by name.
- Elemental combat has real depth. Seven reactive elements create a combat and puzzle language that keeps the moment-to-moment loop fresh long after the novelty of the map wears off.
- Cross-platform and constant content. It plays on phone, PC, and console with shared progress, and ships a new patch region and characters on a fixed cadence, so the game people bought into keeps growing.
The core loop
Explore an open region to collect chests, oculi, and world-quest progress, which feeds a daily-resin economy (Original Resin) you spend on domains and bosses to farm artifacts and level-up materials. You pour those into characters and weapons to raise team power, then use that power to clear harder combat content and the next chapter of the archon/world story. The whole engine is fueled by Primogems, the soft currency you earn from quests and events and convert into gacha 'Wishes' to acquire new limited characters, who become the next thing you level, build, and explore with.
What keeps players coming back
- ↳Daily resin cap and daily commissions: a soft energy system that pulls you back every day so farming progress doesn't stall.
- ↳Limited-time character banners on a patch cadence: each 'wanted' 5-star is time-boxed, and pity-based pulls (guaranteed after a counter) push saving and long-term engagement.
- ↳Recurring seasonal events with Primogem rewards: the events feed the wish economy, so skipping them feels like leaving currency on the table.
- ↳New region every few patches: the archon storyline and a fresh open-world map reset exploration hunger and give lapsed players a reason to return.
- ↳Long, voiced main story: chapter cliffhangers and character arcs give a narrative pull separate from the loot loop.
What players love (22 positive reviews read)
The love is remarkably consistent: this is a beautiful, huge, free open world with strong writing and a soundtrack players single out. Even reviewers who eventually knock the rewards open by praising the exploration, art, and story first. The upside is treated as a given; the fights are about everything wrapped around it.
Open world with plenty of fun things to do and discover, the storyline is fantastic with exciting and emotional parts.
The art style and animation is beautiful and looks like it took a lot of time and effort to make.
I've loved the world building and story and the amazing writing of the characters for five years.
Been playing for about a month and never HAD to spend any money, but did anyway just because I love it.
I love how you get new characters, and it's very rewarding to work hard to get them.
Make sure you get a lyre to play because it sounds so pretty, the music is gorgeous.
% of the 22 positive reviews analyzed, counted, not estimated.
How Genshin Impact makes money (honestly)
Free to download with gacha monetization: optional in-game purchases of premium currency (Genesis Crystals to Primogems) used for randomized character and weapon Wishes, plus a monthly pass (Welkin Moon) and Battle Pass.
Gacha Wishes with pity
Limited 5-star characters are acquired from random pulls; a pity counter guarantees a 5-star after a set number, and a 50/50 system means you may get an off-banner unit first, pushing more pulls.
Dual currency obfuscation
You buy Genesis Crystals with cash, convert to Primogems, then to Wishes, so the real cost of a single desired character is deliberately several layers removed from a dollar figure.
Welkin Moon and Battle Pass
A cheap monthly subscription drip-feeds Primogems daily and a paid Battle Pass tier gives materials and currency, anchoring low-friction recurring spend.
Limited-time banners and reruns
Characters and their signature weapons are time-boxed and only rerun occasionally, manufacturing urgency to pull now rather than wait.
How players react
Divided and loud. Spenders and lore fans defend it as fair-for-a-gacha and note you never MUST pay, but a large, vocal veteran base says free-player income has fallen behind the banner schedule and repeatedly uses the word 'greedy,' demanding it match Honkai: Star Rail's more generous payouts.
The ad twist most articles get wrong
There are no ads inside the game and it does not sell ad space; revenue is entirely gacha and subscription. Its own external user-acquisition marketing (character trailers, cinematics, influencer promos) is heavy, but the in-app experience is ad-free.
What players complain about (37 negative reviews read)
The negativity is dominated by one theme: after years of play, veterans feel the free-currency income no longer keeps up with how many banners release, and they call it greed, often comparing it unfavorably to HoYoverse's own Honkai: Star Rail. Powercreep, phoned-in events, phone performance, and design/representation gripes stack on top. Notably the anger comes from loyal long-term players ('I've played 5-6 years and my favorite game ever, but'), which is why the Play histogram is so bimodal: 2.45M five-stars against 2.02M one-stars.
We don't get enough wishes for a 5-star in one patch anymore, two wanted characters release and f2p get about 60 pulls, it's shamelessly greedy.
The game is fun but so grindy, they barely give rewards, be more like Honkai, you don't give us anything anymore.
I can't play old favorite characters because they're too weak now, powercreep and unsatisfying boss gimmicks will kill this game.
Most of the new events are trash and zero effort, the same minigames over and over, and world quests are absurdly silent.
I love it but it takes up a lot of space and has trouble lagging and loading if you play on your phone.
Bad character designs and no dark-skin characters despite a desert map, plus drama around a voice actor.
% of the 37 negative reviews analyzed, the real weaknesses, and the openings.
How studios like COGNOSPHERE PTE. LTD. (HoYoverse) actually operate
A hit like Genshin Impactisn’t luck, it’s a repeatable playbook. The techniques big mobile studios use:
ASO (App Store Optimization)
Tuning title, subtitle, keywords, screenshots, and icon to rank for what players search and to convert store visits into installs, the same gaps we surface for your own app.
LiveOps & events
A live calendar of events, leaderboards, and limited-time content that gives players a reason to return daily and spend around peaks.
Battle passes & sinks
Recurring passes and currency sinks (lives, coins, extra moves) convert engaged players into repeat spenders without ad clutter.
A/B testing everything
Difficulty curves, prices, offer timing, and UI are constantly tested on cohorts, which is why hard levels so often land right where a purchase helps.
Games like Genshin Impact
Its real rivals on the US top-grossing chart (observed, not invented), tap any we’ve decoded:
HoYoverse's own turn-based gacha RPG and the constant yardstick in Genshin reviews, players say it gives far more free currency and QoL, making it the direct internal rival for the same wallet.
Wuthering Waves
Kuro Games' open-world action gacha built explicitly as a Genshin alternative, competing on faster combat and more generous rewards for the same audience.
Zenless Zone Zero
Another HoYoverse action gacha that pulls from the same player base and marketing engine, splitting attention and spend within the same publisher's catalog.
Tower of Fantasy
An anime open-world MMO-gacha positioned as a Genshin competitor, targeting players who want a shared-world twist on the same fantasy-collect formula.
Honkai Impact 3rd
HoYoverse's earlier action gacha whose combat DNA and collector audience overlap heavily with Genshin, still competing for the studio's loyal fans.
Why you can trust these numbers
- Every theme % is counted from real reviews we read (59 of them), not estimated.
- Ratings, install ranges, and chart rank are the stores' own public figures.
- We never show fabricated downloads or revenue. Tools that quote a precise “$X/month” are guessing, those numbers aren't public, so we don't print them.
Genshin Impact: frequently asked questions
- Is Genshin Impact free, and can you really play without paying?
- Yes, it is free to download and many reviewers report playing for years, sometimes since launch, without ever needing to spend. The catch is the gacha: getting specific limited 5-star characters is where the paid pressure lives, and the top complaint is that free-currency income no longer keeps pace with how many characters release.
- Why is the Google Play rating only about 3.2 when so many people love it?
- The ratings are genuinely split. Of 5.2M Play ratings, roughly 2.45M are 5-star and about 2.02M are 1-star. Long-term fans keep the praise high, while a large veteran base review-bombs over stingy Wish rewards, so the average sits low despite strong sentiment on both ends.
- What do people complain about most?
- By a wide margin, not enough wishes/Primogems for free players relative to the banner schedule, often called 'greedy' and compared to HoYoverse's Honkai: Star Rail. Secondary gripes are powercreep, low-effort repeat events, large download size and phone lag, and character-design and representation debates.
- Does it have ads?
- No. There are no ads in the game and it does not sell ad space. All revenue comes from optional gacha purchases and subscriptions like the Welkin Moon pass.
- Is it better on phone or PC/console?
- Multiple reviewers say it runs and looks noticeably better on PC or console, citing phone lag, loading, and storage size. Progress is shared cross-platform, so many play on phone for convenience and switch to a bigger device for the heaviest content.
The verdict
Genshin Impact earns its place at the top of the grossing charts honestly: it handed the mobile world a real open-world action RPG with console-grade art, a serious soundtrack, and writing that keeps players logging in for years, all free to start. That generosity of scope is exactly why the backlash is so pointed. The people leaving one-star reviews are not tourists, they are five- and six-year veterans who still call it their favorite game, and their grievance is narrow and repeated: the free Wish economy has not scaled with the flood of new banners, so it now reads as greed, especially next to HoYoverse's own more generous Honkai: Star Rail. Powercreep, phoned-in events, phone performance, and design controversies pile on. If you want a gorgeous world to explore and can treat the gacha as optional window-shopping, it is genuinely one of the best free games on the platform. If you need to own every new character without spending, this is a treadmill engineered to make you open your wallet, and the community will be the first to tell you so.
Want this breakdown for your own game?
Glotier reads your real reviews (and your rivals’) and shows you exactly what players praise, what they complain about, and the openings you can win on. Free to start.
Analyze your game freeAnalysis generated 2026-07 from public App Store + Google Play reviews and store listings. Sentiment reflects the reviews sampled, not the entire player base.