GamesProject Makeover
Project Makeover review: why it’s so successful, how it makes money, and what players really say
A makeover-drama story wrapped around a Candy Crush engine, and the wrapper is the whole point.
App Store
4.48★
795K ratings
Google Play
4.52★
1.2M ratings
Installs (Play)
100,000,000+
official range
US grossing
Long-lived top-tier grossing casual title, currently below the visible top 30 US grossing games
US Grossing, Games
What this analysis is
We read 200 recent reviews of Project Makeover across the App Store (200) and Google Play (0), 104 positive and 96 negative, to find what players actually praise and complain about. Every percentage below is counted from those real reviews; the ratings, install range, and chart rank are the stores’ own public figures. We never invent downloads or revenue, those aren’t public, so we don’t pretend to know them. Here’s what makes Project Makeoverwork, and where it doesn’t.
Why Project Makeover is so successful
Checked against Apple's public top-grossing games RSS feed in 2026-07: Project Makeover was not inside the visible top 30 of US grossing games (that band is Pokemon GO, Monopoly GO, Royal Match, Candy Crush, Gossip Harbor, Royal Kingdom, Toon Blast, Match Factory and similar). It sits below that top 30 but remains a durable, heavily monetized charting game, evidenced by 100M+ Play installs, 1.2M Play ratings and 795k App Store ratings. No precise live rank could be verified past position 30, so its standing is described rather than pinned to a fabricated number. A Casual / Match-3 Puzzle game by Magic Tavern, Inc., released 2020-11-15, it combines 2.0M+ total ratings across both stores with a few things players consistently single out:
- The ad-free-until-you-opt-in promise is its loudest selling point. Review after review leads with no ads as the reason they stayed for years, which is rare in match-3 and directly separates it from Candy Crush's forced interstitials.
- It bolts a soap-opera makeover story onto a proven match-3 engine. Players say they keep going to see the next client transformation and the character drama, not just to clear tiles. The puzzle is the fuel, the makeover is the payoff.
- The dress-up and room-decorating layer gives players a reason to play a genre that usually ignores them. Many reviewers name choosing clothes, hair, and furniture as their favorite part, distinct from the match-3.
- Its user-acquisition machine is enormous and infamous. The exaggerated, often AI-generated help-this-woman ads pull massive install volume, and even reviewers who call the ads fake admit the ads are why they downloaded.
- Five-plus years of live-ops (timed makeovers, card collections, seasonal events) drive long-term retention. Many reviewers report playing daily for 3 to 6 years, past level 2000, 4000, even near 9700.
The core loop
Solve a fashion-themed match-3 puzzle level to earn coins, spend those coins on makeover decisions (clothes, hair, makeup, then furniture and room decor) for a dramatic client, and advance the episodic story to the next character reveal. Progress unlocks new levels, avatar customization, and timed events, then the loop repeats with escalating level difficulty and rising item costs.
What keeps players coming back
- ↳Episodic makeover story with cliffhanger client drama that pulls players to the next chapter
- ↳Timed makeover challenges and seasonal events that expire, creating fear-of-missing-out check-ins
- ↳Card-collection sets tied to play that reward daily returns
- ↳Lives/energy timers that pace sessions and bring players back after refills
- ↳Steady 60-levels-per-update content cadence keeping veterans from running out
What players love (104 positive reviews read)
Positive reviewers love that there are no forced ads, that it is addictive and long-lasting, and that the makeover, dress-up, and decorating layer plus the character story make it more than a plain match-3.
Keeps me busy for hours, love that there are no ad pop ups unless you want to watch them for perks.
I started playing this 6 years ago and haven't been able to stop.
I love styling and decorating, it is a good game after a long day.
This game helps me to focus and stay relaxed.
I love learning the stories of the characters and renovating their spaces.
% of the 104 positive reviews analyzed, counted, not estimated.
How Project Makeover makes money (honestly)
Free to play with in-app purchases for coins, gems, extra moves, lives, and event bundles. No mandatory ads, opt-in rewarded video only.
Difficulty gating
Reviewers repeatedly say higher levels become near-impossible without power-ups or extra moves, converting frustration into gem and continue purchases.
Coin inflation on makeovers
Players report item prices climbing at higher levels while a level pays only about 300 coins, widening the gap that real money closes.
Lives / energy timers
Limited lives with slow timed refills create wait friction that a purchase removes instantly.
Event and card bundles
Timed makeover challenges and card-collection events sell shortcut bundles, and some reviewers note bonus purchases now give less for the same or higher price.
How players react
Split. Long-term fans defend the game because it does not force ads, but a large negative bloc calls the late game pay-to-win and says progression is tuned to sell power-ups, with several long-time players saying they are quitting over it.
The ad twist most articles get wrong
In-game ads are genuinely light: no forced interstitials, only opt-in rewarded videos, which players praise. The dishonesty lives entirely in the marketing: pin-pull rescue clips and AI-generated scenes that do not exist in a game that is actually match-3, the number one theme in negative reviews.
What players complain about (96 negative reviews read)
Negative reviewers hammer the misleading ads, aggressive pay-to-progress monetization, difficulty spikes and rigged-feeling levels, lives timers and pop-up clutter, plus a recent wave of update-and-crash bugs.
The game is nothing like the ad, the ad is only a small part, it is really a match-3. False ads.
If you stop spending money you start losing every level, their greed knows no bounds.
You can't even beat the easy levels without power-ups anymore.
New update won't install on my iPad, it downloads then just says update again.
So many pop ups every time you are trying to navigate to something.
% of the 96 negative reviews analyzed, the real weaknesses, and the openings.
How studios like Magic Tavern, Inc. actually operate
A hit like Project Makeoverisn’t luck, it’s a repeatable playbook. The techniques big mobile studios use:
ASO (App Store Optimization)
Tuning title, subtitle, keywords, screenshots, and icon to rank for what players search and to convert store visits into installs, the same gaps we surface for your own app.
LiveOps & events
A live calendar of events, leaderboards, and limited-time content that gives players a reason to return daily and spend around peaks.
Battle passes & sinks
Recurring passes and currency sinks (lives, coins, extra moves) convert engaged players into repeat spenders without ad clutter.
A/B testing everything
Difficulty curves, prices, offer timing, and UI are constantly tested on cohorts, which is why hard levels so often land right where a purchase helps.
Games like Project Makeover
Its real rivals on the US top-grossing chart (observed, not invented), tap any we’ve decoded:
The Playrix template Project Makeover openly copies: a match-3 core wrapped in a renovation-and-story meta, plus the same misleading save-the-scene ad genre.
Direct sibling of Gardenscapes and the closest match-3-plus-decor competitor for the same audience and the same ad style.
The dominant modern match-3 by grossing, competing for the same puzzle spenders and setting the current bar for level design and monetization polish.
The genre archetype reviewers constantly compare it to, and the game Project Makeover's ad-free pitch is explicitly positioned against.
Super Stylist
A fashion-makeover game chasing the same dress-up motivation minus the match-3 spine, for players who came for the makeover not the puzzle.
Why you can trust these numbers
- Every theme % is counted from real reviews we read (200 of them), not estimated.
- Ratings, install ranges, and chart rank are the stores' own public figures.
- We never show fabricated downloads or revenue. Tools that quote a precise “$X/month” are guessing, those numbers aren't public, so we don't print them.
Project Makeover: frequently asked questions
- Is Project Makeover actually the game in the ads?
- No. The ads show pin-pull rescue puzzles and AI-generated scenes that are not in the app. The real game is a match-3 puzzle where clearing levels funds makeover and decorating choices. This mismatch is the single most common complaint in reviews.
- Does it have ads?
- The gameplay is ad-light: no forced interstitials, only opt-in rewarded videos you watch for perks. Reviewers confirm this and cite it as the main reason they stay. The dishonesty is in the marketing ads, not the in-game ad load.
- Can you play for free without spending money?
- Yes for a long time, but many players report the late game (higher levels, item costs, lives) is tuned to pressure purchases, and some call it pay-to-progress once you pass the early hundreds of levels.
- How long is the game?
- Effectively endless. It runs thousands of levels with regular drops of 60 new levels, and long-term reviewers report reaching level 2000, 4000, and beyond over years of play.
- Who makes it?
- Magic Tavern, Inc., which launched Project Makeover in November 2020. It has since grown into one of the largest match-3 makeover titles with 100M+ installs on Google Play.
The verdict
Project Makeover is a well-built match-3 game hiding behind some of the most dishonest advertising in mobile. Strip away the fake pin-pull and AI rescue ads and what you get is a competent, genuinely ad-light Gardenscapes clone with a fun makeover-and-drama wrapper that keeps players hooked for years, which the review counts (795k on iOS, 1.2M on Android, 100M+ installs) confirm. The two things reviewers love, no forced ads and the dress-up story, are real and rare. But the same reviewers split hard on monetization: higher levels feel rigged toward buying power-ups, item prices inflate while payouts stay flat, and lives timers exist to sell impatience. A recent cluster of update-and-crash bug reports adds insult. Honest take: it earns its audience once you are past the door, but it lies to get you through the door, and the late game is tuned to open your wallet.
Want this breakdown for your own game?
Glotier reads your real reviews (and your rivals’) and shows you exactly what players praise, what they complain about, and the openings you can win on. Free to start.
Analyze your game freeAnalysis generated 2026-07 from public App Store + Google Play reviews and store listings. Sentiment reflects the reviews sampled, not the entire player base.